MENSURA decision ledger
Energy decisions read on eight fixed axes, against the official text.
General research record. Not legal advice and not a substitute for counsel.
The eight axes
Every decision is read the same way, so two records can be compared line by line. The structure is the one RISCON PRO SE uses for court decisions, applied to energy.
| 01 | Question | The single question the decision answers. |
|---|---|---|
| 02 | Holding | The passage that answers it, copied character for character from the official text. |
| 03 | Disposition | What the court or regulator ordered. |
| 04 | Form of the test | Whether the authority listed statutory elements, weighed factors or applied an existing rule. |
| 05 | Factors | The considerations named in the text, in its own words. |
| 06 | Relation to precedent | Follows, modifies, first states or distinguishes. |
| 07 | Burden of proof | Who must prove what, if the text says. |
| 08 | Open question and revisit condition | What stays unanswered, and which change in law or fact reopens the record. |
Six seed records, none locked yet
These six Supreme Court of Korea decisions touch grid cost, generation tax, energy contracts and fuel. The disposition and the cross-reading count are PRO SE’s published record, read on 2026-11-19. MENSURA quotes no holding until it has matched one character for character against the official text.
| Case | Decided | Energy question | Disposition (PRO SE) | Axes agreed (PRO SE) | MENSURA status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026Da201517 | 2026-06-05 | Whether a local government’s share of undergrounding costs, paid to an electric utility under Article 72-2 of the Electric Utility Act, is consideration subject to VAT | Dismissed | 6 of 8 | Verbatim lock pending |
| 2025Du32946 | 2025-08-14 | Which construction costs of a nuclear generating facility enter the base of an investment tax credit | Partly reversed and remanded | 7 of 8 | Verbatim lock pending |
| 2012Da74076 | 2017-12-21 | Whether price and exchange-rate adjustment clauses can be excluded by special agreement in a public contract for a district energy facility PRO SE’s published page and an older ledger file disagree on the disposition. Held until the official text settles it. | Held | 8 of 8 | Source conflict |
| 2020Du49539 | 2022-12-01 | Whether refusing to waive a customs surcharge was lawful where LNG carrier freight included capital costs under an amended contract | Reversed and remanded | 7 of 8 | Verbatim lock pending |
| 2017Du48208 | 2019-01-31 | Whether a cover bidder’s surcharge base in a gas trunk pipeline tender includes the subcontractor’s portion of the joint contract | Partly reversed and remanded | 7 of 8 | Verbatim lock pending |
| 2022Du34425 | 2026-05-29 | Which law governs the assignment of a participating interest in an Indonesian production sharing contract | Dismissed | 7 of 8 | Verbatim lock pending |
Rule changes on watch
A tracker entry opens when an official text is pinned. Until then it is a placeholder and says so.
| Item | Dated | Subject | State |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bill No. 2221828 | 2026-10-16 | Amendment to the Environmental Impact Assessment Act: adjustment requests for small-scale assessments | Editorial questions published on PRO SE. Energy-specific questions not yet written. |
| Distributed energy and regional tariffs | not dated | How curtailment compensation and power-system impact assessments treat new data-centre load | Waiting for pinned official texts. No questions published. |
Who does what
MENSURA does
- Pin the official text of a decision or rule
- Read it on the eight axes and publish where two model families disagree
- Keep the revisit condition open
Stays with the operator
- Filing an interconnection or licence application
- Signing a PPA, EPC or finance contract
- Protection settings and live dispatch
- Appeals, litigation and every capital decision